New research published this
week warns that warring couples who stay together for the sake of the children
could do them more harm than good.
A study carried out by
researchers at Cornell University, New York State, found that youngsters whose
parents regularly argue are more likely to drop out of school, use drugs and
binge drink. They are also more likely to have children early and outside
marriage, as well as experience the failure of their own relationship.
The study, called Are Both
Parents Always Better Then One?, found problems could continue into adulthood,
with children from unhappy families prone to mental health disorders.
Kelly Musick, who co-wrote
the report, said: “While children tend to do better living with two biological
married parents, the advantages of living with two continuously-married parents
are not shared equally by all children.”
This is something I have
long known to be true: although previous major research studies have found that
children do best when brought up in two-parent families where couples have made
a long-term commitment to each other, it cannot be good for children to witness
frequent arguments between their parents and live in a tense or frosty
atmosphere.
Unless parents are
extremely good actors, a difficult or hostile relationship will have a negative
effect on children. Youngsters are likely to feel anxious and fearful. They may
also experience feelings of guilt – that it’s somehow their fault that their
parents are constantly at loggerheads. They can become withdrawn and tentative
– frightened to say the wrong thing in case it causes a fresh argument between their
parents.
I would always urge couples
to try to solve their differences when there are children involved, but when it
becomes obvious the relationship is unsalvageable, the better option is to part
as amicably as possible.
If done properly,
separation will be of greater benefit to the children in the long term than if
the parents continue to stay together in a state of malcontent.
Children will be happier if
they see that their parents are happier; and if their parents aren’t caught up
in a cycle of domestic disharmony, they will be able to focus on being more
effective parents.
Couples who decide to
separate rather than struggle on together often find that their relationship
improves once the atmosphere of conflict is removed. Again, this can only be of
benefit to the children.
When parents go their
separate ways, there are also advantages to children in having two homes (and
two bedrooms), two summer holidays and two Christmas and birthday celebrations.

